Ijarah and Ijarah Muntahia Bittamleek - Scope of Standard

Transcription

1. Shari ’ah Standard No. (9): Ijarah and Ijarah Muntahia Bittamleek Statement of the Standard 1. Scope of the Standard This standard covers operating leases of properties or Ijarah Muntahia Bittamleek, whether the Institution is the lessor or the lessee. This standard does not cover Sukuk al-Ijarah al-Ijarah,, as they are covered by Shari’ah Standard on Investment Sukuk, nor the employment of persons (labour contract), as it is covered by a separate standard. 2. Promise to Lease (an Asset) 2/1 In principle, an Ijarah contract is executed for an asset owned by the lessor or an usufruct owned by the sub-lessor. However, it is for a customer to request an Institution to acquire the asset or to acquire the usufruct of an existing asset which the customer wishes to take on lease. 2/2 In principle, Ijarah may be effected directly on the asset without any requirement of a preceding master agreement. However, it is permissible to have a master agreement drawn up coveringa number of Ijarah transactions between the Institution and the customer, setting out the general terms and conditions of agreement between the two parties. In this case, there may either be a separate lease contract for each transaction, in a specific written document signed by the two parties, or alternatively the two parties may exchange notices of offer and acceptance by referring to the terms and conditions contained in the master agreement. 2/3 It is permissible for the Institution to require the customer who has promised to lease to pay a sum of money to the Institution to ensure the customer’s seriousness in accepting a lease on the asset and the subsequent obligations, provided no amount is to be deducted from 238
2. Shari ’ah Standard No. (9): Ijarah and Ijarah Muntahia Bittamleek this sum except in proportion to the actual damage suffered by the Institution in case the customer does not fulfil his promise. Thus, if the customer, in case of Ijarah associated with a promise to transfer ownership, breaches his promise, the promisor shall be charged either the difference between the cost of the asset intended to be leased and the total lease rentals for the asset which is leased on the basis of Ijarah Muntahia Bittamleek to a third party, or, in case of operating Ijarah, the promisor breaching his promise shall be charged the difference between the cost of acquisition and the total selling price if sold to a third party by the Institution (promisee). Otherwise; i.e., in case it is not sold, the promisee shall not be entitled to receive any compensation. 2/4 The amount of money deposited by the customer as security for his commitment can be either held on trust in the custody of the Institution in which case the latter cannot invest it, or it may be held on an investment trust basis in which case the customer permits the Institution to invest it on the basis of Mudarabah between the customer and the Institution. It is permissible to agree with the customer, upon the execution of the contract of lease, that this amount shall be treated as an advance payment of the instalments of the lease rental. 3. Acquisition of the Asset to Be Leased, or Its Usufruct, by the Institution 3/1 For the permissibility of an Ijarah contract concerning a specified asset, the lease contract should be preceded by acquisition of either the asset to be leased or the usufruct of that asset. 3/1/1 If the asset or the usufruct thereof is owned by the Institution, which should in principle be the case, an Ijarah contract may be executed as soon as agreement is reached by the two parties. 3/1/2 However, if the asset is to be acquired by the customer [see item 3/2 below], or by a third party, the Ijarah contract shall not be executed unless and until the Institution has acquired that asset. 239
3. Shari ’ah Standard No. (9): Ijarah and Ijarah Muntahia Bittamleek Ownership is possible under a sale contract, even if the title is not registered in the purchaser’s name (the Institution), and the purchaser has the right to obtain a counter-deed to establish the actual transfer of his ownership of the asset. [see item 3/5 below] 3/2 An asset may be acquired by a party and then leased to that party. In this case, the Ijarah transaction should not be stipulated as a condition of the purchase contract by which the Institution acquires the asset. 3/3 A lessee of an asset may enter into a sub-lease contract with a party other than the owner for a rental that is either the same, lower or higher, payable either currently or on a deferred basis, unless the owner stipulates that the lessee should not assign or sublet the property to third parties, or should not do so without his approval. 3/4 The lessee may lease the asset back to its owner in the first lease period for a rental that is lower, same or higher than what he is paying, if the two rentals are paid on a spot basis. However, this is not permissible if it should lead to contract of ’Inah, by varying the rent or the duration. For example, it is not permissible, if the first rental is one hundred dinars payable on a spot basis, for the lessee to sublet it to the lessor for one hundred and ten dinars payable on a deferred basis, or if the first rental is one hundred and ten dinars payable on a deferred basis, for the second to be for one hundred dinars payable instantly, or if the two rentals are of the same amount, but the payment of the first rental is deferred for one month and the second rental is deferred for two months. 3/5 An Ijarah contract may be executed for an asset undertaken by the lessor to be delivered to the lessee according to accurate specifications, even if the asset so described is not owned by the lessor. In this case, an agreement is reached to make the described asset available during the duration of the contract, giving the lessor the opportunity to acquire or to produce it. It is not a requirement of this lease that the rental should be paid in advance as long as the lease is not executed according to the contract of Salam (or Salaf). Should the lessee receive 240
4. Shari ’ah Standard No. (9): Ijarah and Ijarah Muntahia Bittamleek an asset that does not conform to the description, then he is entitled to reject it and demand an asset that conforms to the description. 3/6 An Institution’s customer may jointly acquire an asset that he wishes to lease with the Institution, and then lease the Institution’s share of the asset from the Institution. In this case, the rental specified as receivable by the Institution should only be in proportion to its share in the ownership of the asset, since the lessee is a co-owner of the asset and therefore has to pay rent only on the share that he does not own. 3/7 An Institution may appoint one of its customers to act as its agent in acquiring on its behalf an asset that is desired by that customer such as equipment, machinery, etc., whose description and price are fixed with a view to the Institution’s leasing such asset or assets to the customer after it has acquired their ownership through either actual or constructive possession. Although this type of agency (for the purchase of the assets) is permissible, it is always preferred that the agent is someone other than the customer (prospective lessee) as far as possible. 4. Concluding an Ijarah Contract and the Forms of Ijarah 4/1 Signature of the contract and the consequences thereof 4/1/1 The lease contract is a binding contract which neither party may terminate or alter without the other’s consent [see items 5/2/2, 7/2/1, and 7/2/2]. However, an Ijarah contract may be terminated in accordance with item 7/2/1. 4/1/2 The duration of an Ijarah contract must be specified in the contract. The period of Ijarah should commence on the date of execution of the contract, unless the two parties agree on a specified future commencement date, resulting in a future Ijarah, that is, an Ijarah contract to be executed at a future date. 4/1/3 If the lessor fails to deliver the asset to the lessee on the date specified in the Ijarah contract, no rental is due for the period 241
5. Shari ’ah Standard No. (9): Ijarah and Ijarah Muntahia Bittamleek between the date specified in the contract and the date of actual delivery, and the rental should be reduced accordingly, unless it is agreed that the lease be extended by an equivalent period after its original expiry date. 4/1/4 ’Arboun (Earnest Money) may be taken in respect of lease at the execution of the contract of lease, with the lessee having the right to terminate the contract during a specified period of time, and ’Arboun is treated as an advance payment of the rental. If the Ijarah contract is not executed for a reason attributable to the lessee, the lessor may retain the ’Arboun. However, it is preferable for the Institution to forgo any amount in excess of the actual damage it has suffered. [see para. 3/2] 4/2 Forms of the Ijarah contract 4/2/1 Ijarah contracts may be executed in respect of the same asset for different periods for several lessees, provided that two contracts are not executed in respect of the same asset for the same period. Such an arrangement is called “successive leases”, because each Ijarah is considered as being successive to the previous one and not concurrent with it on the basis of its being a future Ijarah. [see item 4/1/2 above] 4/2/2 If the lessor signs an Ijarah contract for a particular asset for a specified period of time, he cannot sign another Ijarah contract with another lessee for the duration of the existing Ijarah period or for any remaining period thereof. [see item 7/1/2 below] 4/2/3 An Ijarah contract may be signed with several lessees being entitled to the same specified usufruct of a particular asset and duration of rent, without specifying a particular period of time for a particular person. In this case, each lessee may benefit from the property during the time assigned to him in accordance with specified rules. This case is one form of Muhaya`ah (time-sharing) in benefiting from the usufruct. 242
6. Shari ’ah Standard No. (9): Ijarah and Ijarah Muntahia Bittamleek 4/2/4 A lessee may invite others to share with him in the usufruct he owns. In this case, they become co-owners in the usufruct of the leased property. This can only be done before entering into a sub-lease. If the property is sub-leased after the co-owners having owned the usufruct each co-owner is entitled to a share in the sub-lease rental pro rata to his share in the usufruct. 5. Subject Matter of Ijarah 5/1 Rules governing benefit and leased property 5/1/1 The leased asset must be capable of being used while preserving the asset, and the benefit from an Ijarah must be permissible by Shari’ah. For example, a house or a chattel may not be leased for the purpose of an impermissible act by the lessee, such as leasing premises to be used as headquarters by an Institution dealing in interest or to a shopkeeper for selling or storing prohibited goods, or leasing a vehicle to transport prohibited merchandise. 5/1/2 The subject matter of Ijarah may be a share in an undivided asset held in common with the lessee, whether the lessee is a partner with the lessor or not. In this case the lessee may benefit from the leased share in the same way in which the lessor used to benefit from it, i.e., by usufruct division based on Muhāya’ah i.e. by identifying a particular time (time-sharing) or a particular part of the property, used alternately by the coowners, or any other means with consent of the other partner. 5/1/3 An Ijarah contract may be executed for a house or a chattel, even with a non-Muslim, if the use to be made of it is permissible, such as a house for residential purposes, a car for transport, or a computer to store data, unless the lessor knows in advance, or has reason to presume, that the use of the asset to be leased will be for an impermissible purpose. 5/1/4 The lessee must use the leased asset in a suitable manner or in conformity with common practice, and comply with conditions which are acceptable in Shari’ah. He must also avoid causing 243
7. Shari ’ah Standard No. (9): Ijarah and Ijarah Muntahia Bittamleek damage to the leased asset by misuse through misconduct or negligence. 5/1/5 The lessor must accept responsibility for any defects of the leased asset which impair the intended use of the asset, and may not exclude his liability for any impairment that the leased asset may sustain, either by his own doing or as a result of events outside his control, which affect the benefits intended to be available under the Ijarah contract. 5/1/6 If the benefit from the leased asset is impaired wholly or partially as a result of the lessee’s misconduct, while the property remains under lease, the lessee is obliged to restore or repair the usufruct, and rent for the time during which the benefit is lost is not to be waived. 5/1/7 The lessor may not stipulate that the lessee will undertake the major maintenance of the asset that is required to keep it in the condition necessary to provide the contractual benefits under the lease. The lessor may delegate to the lessee the task of carrying out such maintenance at the lessor’s cost. The lessee should carry out operating or periodical (ordinary) maintenance. 5/1/8 The leased asset is the responsibility of the lessor throughout the duration of the Ijarah, unless the lessee commits misconduct or negligence. The lessor may take out permissible insurance on it whenever possible, and such insurance expenses must be borne by the lessor. The lessor may take this into account implicitly when the lease rental is to be fixed. However, he may not, after the contract is signed, charge the lessee any cost in excess of the cost anticipated at the time of fixing the rent. The lessor may also delegate to the lessee the task of taking out insurance at the lessor’s expense. 5/2 Rules governing lease rentals 5/2/1 The lease rental may be in cash or in kind (goods) or benefit (service). The rental must be specified, either as a lump sum 244
8. Shari ’ah Standard No. (9): Ijarah and Ijarah Muntahia Bittamleek covering the duration of the Ijarah contract, or by instalments for parts of the duration. It may also be for a fixed or variable amount, according to whatever designated method the two parties agree upon. [see item 5/2/3 below] 5/2/2 The rental is made obligatory by the contract and the lessor’s entitlement to the rental runs from the time when the lessee starts to benefit from the asset or once the lessor makes the usufruct of the asset available to the lessee, and the entitlement to the rental does not necessarily commence on the date of signing the Ijarah contract. The rental may be paid entirely in advance or in instalments during a period equivalent, or more or less, to the duration of the Ijarah. However, if the asset is made available only after a period longer than what customary practices deem proper, then no payment shall be obligatory. 5/2/3 In case the rental is subject to changes (floating rental), it is necessary that the amount of the rental of the first period of the Ijarah contract be specified in lump sum. It is then permissible that the rentals for subsequent periods be determined according to a certain benchmark. Such benchmark must be based on a clear formula which is not subject to dispute, because it becomes the determining factor for the rentals of the remaining periods. This benchmark should be subject to a ceiling, on both maximum and minimum levels. 5/2/4 It may be agreed that the rental should consist of two specified parts: one to be paid or transferred to the lessor and the other to be held by the lessee to cover any expenses or costs approved by the lessor, such as the cost of major maintenance, insurance, etc. The excess of the second part of the rental shall be treated as an advance to the lessor on account, while the lessor shall bear any shortage. 5/2/5 The amendment of future rentals is permissible by the agreement of both parties, i.e. the periods for which the lessee has not yet received any benefit. The rentals of any previous periods which 245
9. Shari ’ah Standard No. (9): Ijarah and Ijarah Muntahia Bittamleek have not yet been paid become a debt owed to the lessor by the lessee, and therefore cannot be increased. 6. Guarantees and Treatment of Ijarah Receivables 6/1 Permissible security, of all kinds, may be taken to secure the rental payments or as a security against misuse or negligence on the part of the lessee, such as a charge over assets, guarantees or an assignment of rights over assets of the lessee held by third parties, even if such rights are a permissible life or property insurance indemnity in favour of the lessee. 6/2 The two parties may agree that the rental be paid fully in advance. It is also permissible to make the rent payable in instalments, in which case the lessor may stipulate that the lessee should immediately pay the remaining instalments if he, after receiving a specified period of due notice, delays, without a valid reason, payment of one instalment or more, provided that the asset shall be made available for the lessee to use for the remaining period of time. Any stipulated upfront rental or accelerated -because of delay of payment- rental is subject to settlement at the end of the Ijarah period or, if the Ijarah contract is terminated earlier, at the time of such termination. Any extension of time by the lessor after the stipulated time for prompt payment is considered as a consent to deferral of payment throughout the extension period and not a right of the lessee, subject always to item 5/2/2 above. 6/3 No increase in the rental due may be stipulated by the lessor in case of delay in payment by the lessee. 6/4 It may be provided in the contract of Ijarah or Ijarah Muntahia Bittamleek that a lessee who delays payment for no good reason undertakes to donate a certain amount or percentage of the rental due in case of late payment. Such donation should be paid to charitable causes under the co-ordination of the Institution’s Shari’ah Supervisory Board. 6/5 In case of foreclosure of the security provided by the lessee, the lessor may deduct from such amounts only what is due in respect 246
10. Shari ’ah Standard No. (9): Ijarah and Ijarah Muntahia Bittamleek of rental for previous periods, and not all rental instalments, including instalments which have not yet fallen due and in respect of periods for which the lessee has not had the benefit of the leased asset. The lessor may also deduct from the security all legitimate compensations necessitated by the lessee’s breach of contract. 7. Changes to the Ijarah Contract 7/1 Selling of or damage to the leased asset 7/1/1 If the lessor sells the leased asset to the lessee, the Ijarah contract is terminated due to the transfer of the ownership of the leased asset and ownership of usufruct to the lessee. 7/1/2 The lessor may sell the leased asset to a third party other than the lessee, and the title to the asset together with the rights and obligations of the lessor under the Ijarah contract is thereby transferred to the new owner, because the asset and the rights and obligations attached to it become the right of the third party. The lessee’s consent is not necessary when the lessor decides to sell the asset to a third party. If the purchaser does not know about the Ijarah contract, he may terminate the sale contract, but if he knows about it and consents to it, he takes the place of the previous owner in his entitlement to the rental for the remaining period. 7/1/3 In case of total destruction of the leased asset, the Ijarah contract is terminated if it is concluded on an identified asset. In such a case, it may not be stipulated that the rest of the instalments should be paid. 7/1/4 The leased asset in the possession of the lessee is held by the lessee in a fiduciary capacity on behalf of the lessor. The lessee will not be held liable for any damage or destruction of the leased asset unless such damage or destruction is a result of misconduct or negligence on the part of the lessee. In this case, he is obliged to replace the asset if it is replaceable; otherwise, he is liable for the amount of the damage to be determined by valuation. 247
11. Shari ’ah Standard No. (9): Ijarah and Ijarah Muntahia Bittamleek 7/1/5 In case of the partial destruction of the leased asset in a manner that impairs the benefits expected from the leased asset, the lessee may terminate the Ijarah contract. Both he and the lessor may also agree to amend the rental in case of partial destruction of the leased property, if the lessee waives his right to termination. The lessor in this case is not entitled to rent for the period during which the lessee was not able to benefit from the asset unless the lessor makes it up (by agreement with the lessee) with a like benefit after the expiry of the period specified in the contract. [see para. 5/1/6] 7/1/6 In an Ijarah Mawsufah fi al-Dhimmah (contract for an unidentified asset undertaken by the lessor to be delivered according to the agreed specifications), the owner in cases of total and partial destruction must offer an alternative asset having a specification similar to that of the destroyed asset, unless otherwise agreed at the time. The Ijarah shall continue for the remaining time of the contract. If it is not possible to provide a substitute asset, the contract will be terminated. [see item 3/5] 7/1/7 If the lessee stops using the leased asset or returns it to the owner without the owner’s consent, the rental will continue to be due in respect of the remaining period of the Ijarah, and the lessor may not lease the property to another lessee for this period, but must keep it at the disposal of the current lessee unless the lessee relinquishes to the lessor the remaining period of time, in which case the lease expires. [see item 7/2/1 below] 7/2 Termination, expiry and renewal of the Ijarah contract 7/2/1 It is permissible to terminate the lease contract by mutual consent but it is not permissible for one party to terminate it except in case of force majeure or there is a defect in the leased asset that materially impairs its use. Termination is also possible when one party secures an option to terminate the contract in which case the party who holds the option may exercise it during the specified period. 248
12. Shari ’ah Standard No. (9): Ijarah and Ijarah Muntahia Bittamleek 7/2/2 The lessor may stipulate that the Ijarah contract be terminated if the lessee does not pay the rent or fails to pay it on time. 7/2/3 An Ijarah contract does not terminate with the death of either party thereto. However, the heirs of the lessee may terminate the Ijarah contract if they can prove that the contract has become, as a result of the death of their legator, too onerous for their resources and in excess of their needs. 7/2/4 An Ijarah contract expires with the total destruction of the leased asset in the case of leasing a specific asset or with the inability to enjoy the usufruct owing to the loss of the benefit that the asset was intended to provide. 7/2/5 The two parties may terminate the Ijarah contract before it begins to run. 7/2/6 The lease expires upon the expiry of its term, but it may remain operative for a good cause, such as the late arrival to the place intended in the lease of transportation vehicles, and in the case of a late harvesting period for land leased for crop cultivation. The lease then continues with the rental based on the prevailing market value. An Ijarah may be renewed for another term, and such renewal may be made before the expiry of the original term or automatically by adding a provision in the new contract for such renewal when the new term starts, unless either party serves a notice on the other of its desire not to renew the contract. 8. Transfer of the Ownership in the Leased Property in Ijarah Muntahia Bittamleek 8/1 In Ijarah Muntahia Bittamleek, the method of transferring the title in the leased asset to the lessee must be evidenced in a document separate from the Ijarah contract document, using one of the following methods: a) By means of a promise to sell for a token or other consideration, or by accelerating the payment of the remaining amount of rental, or by paying the market value of the leased property. 249
13. Shari ’ah Standard No. (9): Ijarah and Ijarah Muntahia Bittamleek b) A promise to give it as a gift (for no consideration). c) A promise to give it as a gift, contingent upon the payment of the remaining instalments. In all these cases, the separate document evidencing a promise of gift, promise of sale or a promise of gift contingent on a particular event, should be independent of the contract of Ijarah Muntahia Bittamleek and cannot be taken as an integral part of the contract of Ijarah. 8/2 A promise to transfer the ownership by way of one of the methods specified in item 8/1 above is a binding promise by the lessor. However, a binding promise is binding on one party only, while the other party must have the option not to proceed. This is to avoid a bilateral promise by the two parties which is Shari’ah impermissible because it resembles a concluded contract. 8/3 In all cases of transfer of ownership by way of gift or sale, it is necessary, when the promise is fulfilled, that a new contract be drawn up, since the ownership to the property is not automatically transferred by virtue of the original promise document that was drawn up earlier. 8/4 In case the Ijarah contract is combined, through a separate document, with a gift contingent upon the condition that the remaining rent instalments be paid, the ownership to the leased property is transferred to the lessee if the condition is fulfilled, without the need for any other procedure to be adopted or a document to be signed. However, if the lessee’s payment is short of even one instalment, the ownership to the property is not transferred to him, since the condition has not been fulfilled. 8/5 If the leased asset was purchased from the lessee before it was leased back to the lessee on the basis of Ijarah Muntahia Bittamleek, a (reasonable) period of time, between the lease contract and the time of the sale of the asset to the lessee, must have expired, to avoid the contract of ’Inah. This period must be long enough so that the leased property or its value could have changed. This shall 250
14. Shari ’ah Standard No. (9): Ijarah and Ijarah Muntahia Bittamleek also apply to the case of early ownership of the asset where a sale contract is concluded during the Ijarah. [see para. 7/1] 8/6 Subject to item 8/8 below, the rules governing Ijarah must apply to the Ijarah Muntahia Bittamleek, i.e. when a promise is made by the lessor to transfer the ownership in the leased asset to the lessee. None of these rules should be breached under the pretext that the leased asset was bought by the lessor on the basis of a promise by the lessee that he would acquire it or that ownership of it would devolve upon him, or that he would pay rentals in excess of those payable in respect of a similar property which are similar in amount to the instalments of an instalment sale, or that local laws and conventional banking practices consider such a transaction as an instalment sale with a deferred transfer of the ownership. 8/7 Transfer of the ownership in the leased property cannot be made by executing, along with the Ijarah, a sale contract that will become effective on a future date. 8/8 If the leased asset is destroyed or if the continuity of the lease contract becomes impossible up to the expiry period without the cause being attributable to the lessee in either case, then the rental is adjusted based on the prevailing market value. That is, the difference between the prevailing rate of rental and the rental specified in the contract must be refunded to the lessee if the latter rental is higher than the former. This is to avoid loss to the lessee, who agreed to a higher rental payment compared to the prevailing rate of rental in consideration of the lessor’s promise to pass the title to him upon the expiry of the lease term. 9. Date of Issuance of the Standard This Standard was issued on 4 Rabi’ I, 1423 A.H., corresponding to 16 May 2002 A.D. 251