IslamicMarkets uses cookies.
About our cookie policy.

Sign in to continue reading...

An Empirical Study of Shariah Legitimacy of Islamic Banking Operations in Pakistan

Muhammad Khaleequzzaman
By Muhammad Khaleequzzaman
2 weeks ago
An Empirical Study of Sharīʿah Legitimacy of Islamic Banking Operations in Pakistan

Fatwa, Islamic banking, Maqasid, Sunnah

Create FREE account or Login to add your comment


  1. An Empirical Study of Shar īʿah Legitimacy of Islamic Banking Operations in Pakistan Muhammad Khaleequzzaman Muhammad Tahir Mansuri Abdul Rashid Abstract The legitimacy of Islamic banking refers to the compliance with the precepts of Sharīʿah (Islamic law) of the pronouncements and their implementation, requisites of various contracts, as well as, realization of the welfare objectives. Therefore, the Islamic banks are supposed to follow the Islamic values focused to bring benefit to the society alongside the commercial motive. These distinguishing features establish identity of the Islamic banks separate from their conventional counterparts and require pursuing normative values of Islamic injunctions. The primary focus of this research is two folds: firstly, considering the legitimacy of Islamic banking practices in holistic perspective including normative concerns directed by Sharīʿah, and secondly, to gauge the perception of the customers of Islamic and conventional banks about the aforementioned approach of Sharīʿah legitimacy. The research has been commissioned by developing the constructs of Sharīʿah legitimacy through extensive review of the relevant literature. At the same time, the empirical analysis based on the opinion of 836 customers of Islamic and conventional banks in all the four provinces and the capital city of Pakistan has produced important conclusions regarding their perception about legitimacy of the Islamic banking practices. The key finding in the theoretical perspective is that the value judgements have been grossly ignored by the Islamic banks. The empirical research indicated that about half of the customers perceived Islamic banking as Sharīʿah legitimate. On overall basis, the other half viewed contrary to this or preferred to remain indifferent. There is a dire need that Islamic banks should look into the desired goals of Sharīʿah legitimacy in both contexts; the value judgement and the perception of the customers. Keywords: Islamic banking; Sharīʿah legitimacy; Maqāṣid al-Sharīʿah; Value judgment; Distributive justice. KAUJIE Classification: B4, L0, K1, N0 JEL Classification: D12, I3, M14, Z12 INTRODUCTION Accordingly, the Islamic banks, besides pursuing their business interests, ought to render the value judgements derived through maṣāliḥ (public interest at large) of the mankind. This has been emphasized by a number of research studies, for example Ahmed (2006), Laldin (2013), Dusuki and Nurdianawati ((2007), Mohammed (2008), and Ahmed (2011). Accordingly, Islamic Law dispenses justice, mercy, benefit, and wisdom. And, anything contrary to these values does not deem originating from the Law (Attia, 2007). The legitimacy of Islamic banking operations should, as such, refer to the compliance with the precepts of Sharīʿah (Islamic law), requisites of various contracts and operational processes, as well as, observance of the normative values resulting from the Islamic injunctions. The legitimacy of Islamic banking, Rosly (2006), suggests should, therefore, be perceived through maqāṣid al-Sharīʿah, alongside the commercial motivation. The literature suggests that public opinion provides important basis for legitimizing the actions of any organization as concluded by Berrone and Fosfuri (2009) and Hough and Bradford (2013). Suchman (1995) 1
  2. arrives at similar conclusion that various stakeholders , too, understand that such actions could be approved only when they meet the criteria of appropriateness within a framework of social norms, values, and beliefs. Similarly, Ozkan (2014) and Rafay (2015) reach at the same inference that the organizations should operate in line with expectations of the concerned stakeholders. We therefore, understand that the opinion of the customers of Islamic and conventional banks helps evaluating legitimacy of the Islamic banking operations. Hence, the primary focus of this paper rests with to evaluate operations of Islamic banks in Pakistan in terms of their value-oriented contributions to the society and to empirically explore the opinion of the customers about Sharīʿah legitimacy of current Islamic banking operations. The paper attempts building future outlook of Islamic banks by enhancing efficiency and impact through value judgments. The main research area, as such, relates to the need to evaluate the operations of Islamic banks in the light of maqāṣid al-Sharīʿah, that is, whether or not the normative concerns have been attended to in addition to compliance of the operations with the prescribed contract mechanism. The policy implications for Islamic banking industry have been drawn in the light of Islamic values to facilitate achieving legitimacy of Islamic banking operations in the aforementioned context. The rest of the paper is structured as follows. Section II presents the theoretical framework consisting of the requisites of Sharīʿah legitimacy of Islamic banking operations and review of current practices vis-a-vis normative values. Section III elaborates the methodology of empirical research including criteria for selecting the respondents, sample frame, design of questionnaire, conduct of survey, and techniques of data analysis. Section IV comprises results and interpretation of the empirical research, while Section V presents the conclusions and policy implications for the Islamic banking industry in Pakistan. I. THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK This section identifies the Islamic law as distinguished from the positive/man-made laws, by its origin, comprehensiveness, and universality, as well as, its application to the contemporary Islamic banking operations. A. Islamic Law and Sharīʿah Legitimacy of Islamic Banking Operations Interchangeably understood as Sharīʿah, the Islamic Law consists of aḥkām e Sharaʿī [sing. ḥukm: a communication from the God Almighty) related to the human act(s). The jurists have classified the sources of Islamic laws into two broad categories, viz. (i) primary or material sources – Qur’ān (The communication of the God Almighty that was revealed to the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) and Sunnah (the practice of the Prophet PBUH) and (ii) secondary or rational sources based on human reasoning but are in conformity with the principles set by the primary sources. Necessarily, the secondary sources have been formulated through ijmāʿ (consensus of opinions) and presents agreement of those who are qualified to hold ijtihād (Nyazee, 2006). Sharīʿah legitimacy for the Islamic banking practices refers, generally to the conformity of the fatāwá (pronouncements) pertaining to the financial transactions to the Sharīʿah requisites and their application to such practices and related procedures and processes. However, observing moral virtues as enjoined by the Sharīʿah are ignored. Accordingly, the holistic approach provides the prime basis of the research that takes into account both the compliance with contractual mechanism and the normative concerns of the society. B. Maqāṣid al-Sharīʿah and Maṣāliḥ – Bases of Inductive Reasoning The theory of maqāṣid is supported by an inductive analysis of the Islamic Law. Lexically, the term, maqāṣid al-Sharīʿah, means facilitation for drawing benefit and repulsion of harm. Al-Raysuni (2005) cites 2
  3. the work of Al-Shatibi (in Al-Muwafaqat fi usul al Sharīʿah) and holds that the Law has been established to serve human interests in both the life in this world and the hereafter. The inductive examination of aḥkām, therefore, concludes that the rules prescribed by Sharīʿah are based on inner reasons and cause ultimate benefit the society and the individuals, and that, in the words of Ibn Ashur “all-purpose principle of the Sharīʿah is to achieve righteousness and goodness in the world and remove corruption from it” (El-Mesawi, 2006). That is why the maṣāliḥ based ijtihād has led to expand the scope of Islamic Law to extensively cover the normative obligations. In the same perspective, even maṣāliḥ mursalah being unrestricted and contained through juristic argument are deemed valid for a new universal good for the community and render their applicability as binding evidence (Kharoufa, 2000). Therefore, it becomes essential to allow what is beneficial and to avoid what is harmful for the community under all circumstances, especially when facing unprecedented problems and pressing diversity. As such, the question about validity and sustainability of Islamic banking arises and requires reviewing against the precepts of Islam for ensuring equity, fair distribution of resources, and equitable opportunity. While such values are opted by choice in conventional finance, these are essentially required in Islamic finance. C. Review of Islamic Banking Operations in Pakistan vis a vis Normative Values This sub-section reviews the Islamic banking operations and their relevance to the maqāṣid al-Sharīʿah with a view to ascertain compliance with value judgements. As depicted from the statistics issued by State Bank of Pakistan (2015), the major part of resources (70.54% of total financing) had been invested in fixed return instruments, i.e. murābaḥah (cost plus sale transaction), ijārah (Islamic lease), and diminishing mushārakah (underlying contract of which is ijārah, giving the banks fixed rentals). The mushārakah, mainly in the name of running mushārakah 1, occupied 11.39% of total financing and the rest 17.99% for other modes like Salam and istiṣnāʿ. Contrary to this, the modes embedded with compassionate concerns like muḍārabah (A type of partnership where capital and management are provided by two distinct partners and business profits ae shared) and qarḍ ḥasan (an interest free loan), respectively, amounted to only 0.05% and 0% of the total financing, reflecting indifferent attitude of banks towards social conduct for the weaker segments of the society. It is pertinent to indicate that the customers value profit sharing products more than the fixed returns (Khan et al., 2007) as the latter resemble conventional banking practices. Certainly, ignoring peoples’ expectations would result in adverse opinion of customers about the subject legitimacy. The sectoral analysis, too, reveals that Islamic banks were serving the cause of corporate sector more as compared to the trend of banking industry as a whole. Similarly, the Islamic banks’ share in agricultural financing was negligible as compared to the banking industry (Khaleequzzaman et al. 2016). On the other hand, the statistics presented by the State Bank of Pakistan (2014) exhibit Islamic banks holding greater cash and balances to total assets and lower financing to deposit ratio than the banking industry. However, the Islamic banks have not adopted ways and means to invest excess liquidity in avenues like small and microenterprises, already grossly neglected by the both Islamic and conventional banks. In the same context, IFSB (2013) also, emphasizes to embark policy move to link previously neglected market niches by the commercially oriented financial institutions and prescribes that the Sharīʿah compliance should not be enough without responding to the ethical issues of poverty alleviation, financial inclusion, and responsible investments. D. Conclusion Running Mushārakah has been designed to serve the working capital need of the corporate sector but is devoid of the basic features pertaining to the mode of Mushārakah. 1 3
  4. The most important conclusion of this section suggests that the Shar īʿah legitimacy of Islamic banking practices should be understood in holistic perspective, rather than mere adherence to the compliance requirements applicable to the products and contracts/documentation of the related transactions. The normative concerns prescribed by Sharīʿah should be considered integral part of the legitimacy framework. It has been established that the application of the Islamic law is rationalized through maqāṣid al-Sharīʿah and is reflected through intent of the Lawgiver focused on welfare of the subjects. This foundation leads to the theory of maṣāliḥ whereby the benefit has to be realized and the harm prevented. That is why; the Islamic banks should be pre-occupied with normative move by instilling socially responsible behavior and altruism as against self-centered conventional finance. II. METHODOLOGY OF EMPIRICAL RESEARCH We have taken benefit of the theoretical framework in two respects, viz. determining constructs of Sharīʿah legitimacy of Islamic banking practices on one hand and using such constructs to conduct empirical research by gathering the opinion of customers about the subject on the other. The latter aspect has helped assessing sustainability of Islamic banks in case their practices met the perceived outlook of the banking customers. Our research is descriptive in nature and aims to explain the opinion of the customers on the Islamic banking practices. Following the literature such as Adanza (2006) and Kothari (2004), this research also conforms to the procedure of investigation describing and interpreting the existing relationships, beliefs and trends developed among various customers. Further, as suggested by several researchers like Kothari (2004) we have applied both qualitative and quantitative techniques to arrive at the robust and credible findings. Our approach has been deductive where theorization has been used as a basis to conduct empirical part of the research (Blackstone, 2012). A. Selection of Respondents Following Bhattacherjee (2012) and Mishkin (2003), those stakeholder have been identified for the research who could express their opinion independently without any conflict of interest and who are considered essential in terms of our objectives. The shareholders, Sharīʿah advisors/members of Sharīʿah boards, Sharīʿah audit staff, internal auditors, and boards of directors of Islamic banks have not been considered to avoid any bias. The regulator (primarily, the State Bank of Pakistan) has also been excluded for the reason that all policy guidelines for Islamic banks are developed and enforced by SBP; therefore it becomes an interested party. The external auditors have also not been considered, as they do not disclose the affairs about their clients owing to the confidentiality requirement. Accordingly, we have selected the most related stakeholders’ group that include the customers of Islamic and conventional banks. Over time, the existence and operation of Islamic banks have raised awareness of the general public about the Islamic banking practices. Such conclusions have been drawn by Ahmad and Bashir (2014), Echchabi and Aziz (2012), and Imran et al. (2011). Therefore, the customers are concerned with the Sharīʿah compliance of the Islamic banking products and services, a reason for which they join the Islamic banks in the first place. On the other hand, SBP’s KAP study conducted by State Bank of Pakistan and Department for International Development (2014) reports thatt about 74% of the banked respondents expressed strong inclination to switch to Islamic bank. The study further explores that the customers of conventional banks have also expressed pent up demand to shift to the Islamic banks, presumably out of their own awareness about and the belief in Islamic banking. As inferred by Masood et al. (2014), it is also evident that the customers of Islamic and conventional banks form their opinion about Islamic banking practices, and forward preferences and apprehensions in this respect, even about knowledge of the employees about Islamic banking. Therefore, the customers of Islamic and conventional banks present one of the most relevant segments of respondents in our research. 4
  5. B . Sample Frame Many studies conducted in Pakistan have extracted the sample based on the proportion of population spread over various provinces. However, owing to the smallness of the banked population in Pakistan (11%) disproportionately spread among provinces (Pakistan Microfinance Network, 2009), we have instead used the spread of the Islamic banking branches for selection of the customers as they were to be interviewed in the branches. Therefore, the sample of customers has been drawn in proportion to the concentration of Islamic banking branches in the provinces and the Islamabad Capital Territory (ICT), combined with random selection process. The spread of Islamic banking branches has been taken from SBP’s Islamic Banking Bulletin, December 2014 for ICT and four provinces of the country. We have however not considered Federally Administered Territories for security reasons and Gilgit-Baltistan (GB), and Azad Jammu and Kashmir (AJK) being distant and difficult areas, following Pew Research Centre. (2012), Nenova et al. (2009), and Zaidi (2010). In all, a sample of 850 customers was targeted; however, the response could be collected from 836, constituting an encouraging response rate of 98%. The size of our sample was larger than the other studies having focus on Islamic banking perception but targeting smaller samples in other studies like Ahmad and Bashir (2014) and Dusuki and Dar (2005) that surveyed 200 and 750 respondents, respectively. C. Survey Instrument Anonymous and bi-lingual (in both English and the national language i.e. Urdu) questionnaires were structured to allow, respectively, confidentiality and convenience of filling the requisite data. All the questions were grouped in different blocks in keeping with the objectives of the research and based on various factors (dimensions) of legitimacy extracted with the help of literature reviewed and theoretical framework developed for this research. Each factor consisted of four items (questions) focusing the main theme of the dimension. The dimension of the questionnaire common to each category of respondents styled as ‘Sharīʿah legitimacy’ was chosen as dependent variable as all other dimensions, in one way or the other, explained the opinion of respondents about Sharīʿah legitimacy of the current Islamic banking practices. All the other factors/dimensions, therefore, represented independent variables (See Table 1). TABLE 1 FACTORS AND ITEMS Factor Question/Item Dependent Variable Sharīʿah 1. The current Islamic banking practices are Sharīʿah compliant. Legitimacy 2. The current Islamic banking practices follow the teachings of Qur’ān, Sunnah, and ijmāʿ. 3. Islamic banking practices are free from ribā (interest). 4. Islamic banking is based on profit and loss sharing principle. Explanatory Variables Performance 1. Islamic banks perform better than conventional banks. 2. Islamic banks provide individual attention to customers more than conventional banks provide. 3. Islamic banks carry better image and reputation than conventional banks. 4. The service of Islamic banks is faster than conventional banks. Optimism Social justice 1. I believe that Islamic banks will progress in future because of more dedication towards Islamic principles. 2. Islamic banks are expected to refine their practices to become more Sharīʿah compliant in future. 3. Islamic banks are expected to improve their behavior to the customers. 4. Islamic banks are expected to disburse qarḍ ḥasan to meet needs of the poor people. 1. Islamic banking practices promote social justice in the society. 2. Islamic banking promotes better circulation of wealth. 3. Islamic banks offer equity-based financing where they share the risk of loss with the client. 4. There is no gender segregation in availing financial services from Islamic banks. 5
  6. Products ’ compliance Fair treatment Criticism 1. The products offered by Islamic banks are Sharīʿah compliant. 2. The products are Sharīʿah compliant because they are approved by Sharīʿah advisor. 3. The products are Sharīʿah compliant because they are offered by Islamic banks. 4. The products are Sharīʿah compliant because we trust that they fulfil the Sharīʿah requirements. 1. Islamic banking practices extend fair treatment to all of their customers. 2. Islamic banks extend fair returns to all depositors. 3. Islamic banks charge lower rate of profit while financing small clients as compared to corporate clients. 4. The terms and conditions in the financial contracts are balanced and do not turn in favor of banks at the cost of clients. 1. Islamic banking faces criticism from different quarters which restricts me to believe in this system. 2. I am not convinced that Islamic banking is Sharīʿah legitimate. 3. Islamic banking products and practices are not based on Islamic injunctions. 4. Islamic banking is in fact another name of the conventional banking. D. Data Collection and Analysis The filled questionnaires, duly serial numbered and signed by the enumerators, were fed to excel sheet separately for each category of respondents. All data had been coded for analytical purpose and then transferred to the data analysis software. The analysis was started with univariate statistics, primarily to arrive at basic results like distribution of responses, ascertaining frequencies of various Likert scale points, and identifying and treating missing values, if any. Cross tabulation helped to workout joint frequency distribution of two or more variables. Therefore, the demographic profiles and bank information about the respondents has been cross tabulated against the questions pertaining to the opinion of the customers. Factor analysis has enabled data reduction where certain variables have clustered together meaningfully (Field, 2009). However, we are concerned with the issue that the items do not measure the multiple factors to determine the goodness of fit of the model as prescribed by Pallant (2005). As suggested by the literature, such as Field (2009), Field (2000), Choong et al. (2012), and Landau and Everitt (2004), we have considered various thresholds/critical values related to communalities, eigenvalues, scree plot, varimax rotation, factor loading, etc. to ensure robustness of the factor analysis. We have conducted reliability test of the sample data by computing Cronbach's Alpha to measure internal consistency through coefficient of reliability in case of Likert type scale. The values of cronbach’s alpha, as shown in Table 2, for all variables were well above the threshold of 0.6 as suggested by Choong et al. (2012), Gan et al. (2011), and Mawoli et al. (2011), hence proving greater internal consistency at preferred scale suggested as above. Therefore, all the variables were deemed reliable. TABLE 2 CRONBACH’S ALPHA Factor 1. Sharīʿah Cronbach’s Alpha No. of Items 0.875 4 legitimacy 2. Performance 0.862 4 3. Optimism 0.860 4 4. Social justice 0.816 4 5. Products’ 0.921 4 compliance 6. Fair treatment 0.815 4 7. Criticism 0.774 4 6
  7. Our KMO ’s sample adequacy value is more than 0.5 (Table 3) as suggested by Field (2009) and the Bartlett Test of Sphericity is significant at p < 0.01. Both the results help to assess factorability of the variables. TABLE 3 FACTOR ANALYSIS Factor Sharīʿah legitimacy Performance Optimism Social justice Products’ compliance Fair treatment Criticism Item Factor Loadings KMO 1 2 3 4 I 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 0.805 0.869 0.839 0.681 0.706 0.870 0.765 0.792 0.820 0.836 0.819 0.654 0.745 0.760 0.790 0.607 0.837 0.904 0.822 0.888 0.820 df 6 Sig. 0.000 0.812 6 0.000 0.781 6 0.000 0.783 6 0.000 0.848 6 0.000 0.685 0.826 0.655 0.735 0.782 6 0.000 0.574 0.632 0.848 0.682 0.727 6 0.000 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 Bartlett's Test of Sphericity E. Factor Analysis As shown in Table 3, the data pass the validity test as the Bartlett’s test results are significant in all variables and prove that R-matrix is different from identity matrix, therefore, our factor analysis turns to be appropriate (Pallant ,2005, Field, 2000, and Choong et al., 2012). All variables in our sample show eigenvalue more than 1.0 and hence rule out the possibility of multicollinearity [43]. Factor loadings define substantive importance of a variable to the factor (Field, 2000). The factor loadings in our sample range from 0.607 to 0.904, explaining 37% to 82% variance of the variables correspond to the ones suggested by the literature like Field (2009) and turn to be more adequate than the prescribed standard. A. Regression Analysis We have conducted linear regression analysis in a cross-sectional framework by using Ordinary Least Squares (OLS). The general form of the regression model is presented in “(1)”. 7
  8. Yi = β0 + β1X1i + β2X2i + … + βk Xki + εi (1) where:  k represents number of explanatory variables and i represents the i th number of respondent.  The multiple regression model for a dependent variable, Y, with observed values, Y 1, Y2,…,YN and k independent or explanatory variables with observed values X1, X2,…, XN where i=1, 2, …, N  The term εi is the residual or error for the ith respondent variable and represents the deviation of the observed value of the response from expected value of the model.  The regression coefficients β0, β1, β2,…, βk are estimated through least squares. We have developed the base regression model shown as “(2)”. (Sharīʿah = β0 + β1(Performance)i + β2(Optimism)i + β3(Social justice)i + β4(Products’ legitimacy) i +Compliance) i + β5(Fair treatment)i + β6(Criticism)i + εi (2) The dependent and explanatory variables are defined in Table 1. We have extended our base model to include demographic variables (dummies), viz. Gender, Income Level, Age, Province of residence, and Education. As prescribed by Newbold (1984), the inclusion of demographic variables has helped to predict the dependent variable more precisely as they may affect variance in dependent variable. We have included dummies for all categories and excluded intercept from regression. We have preferred this approach over regression with an intercept term and inclusion of dummy variables one less than the number of categories for the reason that this approach enables us to directly compare the estimates across categories. We have also excluded data for ‘no response’ from regression analysis of those dummy variables where such data has been found, however ‘no response’ data has not been excluded from other regression models as the dummies are not the variables in bi-variate or multi-variate regression. That is why the ‘no response’ does not appear in the impact of dependent variable. However, one should note that proportion of ‘no responses’ is quite low. III. EMPIRICAL RESULTS AND INTERPRETATION This section discusses the empirical findings arrived at through various statistical tools (univariate, bivariate and multivariate analyses). The descriptive statistics has been used to explain about the frequencies/proportions and results of cross tabulation/joint frequencies. The results of regression analysis have, first, helped to see the simultaneous impact of all the variables on the dependent variable and, second, to observe the effect of demographic variables inclusively. A. Descriptive Statistics Most of the respondents (87.2%) representing male gender, were from young and middle-aged groups (84.3%), had achieved middle level education (51.2%) and lived in urban areas (93%). The major proportion of respondents (68.4%) was earning income up to Rs.100, 000 (against per capita income of Rs. 157,605 as reported by the Pakistan Economic Survey 2015-2016 published by the Ministry of Finance, Government of Pakistan). About 52% respondents had relationship with the Islamic banks, more popularly using current and saving accounts, debit card, car ijārah and diminishing mushārakah. The data on various dimensions of Sharīʿah legitimacy, collected on five point Likert scale, reflected that about half of the respondents (40-46%) agreed that the current Islamic banking practices were Sharīʿah compliant, followed the teachings of Qur’ān and Sunnah, were free from ribā, and based on the principle of profit and loss sharing while the rest preferred not to agree with these dimensions or remain indifferent. Ribā in any exchange or sale contract is defined by fiqh scholars as “an unlawful gain derived from the quantitative inequality of the counter values in any transaction purporting to effect the exchange of two or more species (anwāʿ), which belong to the same genus (jins) and are governed by the same efficient cause (ʿillah) (Obaidullah, 2011 citing from Salih, 1992). 8
  9. The proportion of those who agreed strongly that practices of Islamic banks were compliant with Shar īʿah was, however, lower (18-20%) than those who just agreed (24-28%). About half of the respondents perceived Islamic banks performing better than the conventional banks, owing mainly due to better image. On overall basis, about half of the respondents were convinced that Islamic banking practices were Sharīʿah compliant and meeting, in one way or the other, the social values embedded in maqāṣid alSharīʿah. But, at the same time, one cannot ignore the proportion of the respondents that have disagreed or remained indifferent on account of these dimensions. Although, disagreeing can be differentiated from being indifferent, yet taking together constitutes the other half whose opinion cannot be simply ignored. The outcome of the joint frequencies of various dimensions of Sharīʿah legitimacy and demographic variables has led to important conclusions. The firmest believers of Islamic banking practices were found in Baluchistan province, followed by KPK, Punjab, ICT, and Sindh provinces of the country. More or less, the similar ranking among the provinces was found while assessing proportion of the customers believing that Islamic banking practices were based on: i) Qur’ān and Sunnah (KPK: 71.6%; Balochistan: 53.0%; Punjab: 37.5%; Sindh: 33.7%; and Federal Capital: 25.6%); ii) principle of profit and loss sharing Sunnah (Balochistan: 76.4%; KPK: 63.2%; Punjab: 50.0%; Sindh: 32.9%; and Federal Capital: 32.6%), and iii) free from ribā (Balochistan: 76.5%; KPK: 70.5%; Punjab: 41.9%; Federal Capital: 37.2%; and Sindh: 30.0%). Such results are also confirmed by the KAP study conducted by SBP (2014). The analysis of the different age groups believing in legitimacy of Islamic banking practices reveals that the younger (18-40 years) and middle-aged (41-50 years) people believed more in this context than the older ones (51 years and over), depicting that the Islamic banking was more popular among younger generation. B. Regression Analysis The results of the regression analysis as shown in Table 4 reveal that independent variables (Performance, Optimism, Social justice, Products’ compliance, Fair treatment, and Criticism) significantly affect the dependent variable. The adjusted R2 (0.573) reveals that the model has explained 57.3% variance in the dependent variable. The F-statistic suggest that, overall, the model is a good fit as the associated pvalue is considerably below the acceptable level of significance. Since the collinearity statistics indicate the value of VIF<10 and Tolerance Level>0.1 for all variables, our model is saved from multicollinearity. TABLE 4 RESULTS OF REGRESSION ANALYSIS Predictor 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Constant Performance Optimism Social justice Products’ compliance Fair treatment Criticism Dependent variable R2 Adjusted R2 F-statistic Standardized Coefficients β t-stat 0.000 3.564 3.738 2.070 10.99 7 0.025 0.691 -0.175 7.427 ‘Sharīʿah legitimacy’ 0.128 0.151 0.083 0.423 P-value Collinearity Statistics Toleranc VIF e 1.000 0.000 0.000 0.039 0.000 0.399 0.312 0.320 0.347 2.507 3.204 3.129 2.886 0.490 0.000 0.405 0.926 2.469 1.080 0.576 0.573 187.629 9
  10. P-value of Fstatistic 0 .000 The estimated coefficients indicate that ‘Performance’, ‘Optimism’, ‘Social justice’ and Products’ compliance’ leave positive, while ‘Criticism’ leaves negative impact on ‘Sharīʿah legitimacy’. The positive values of the estimated coefficients suggest that the customers’ perceptions about ‘Sharīʿah legitimacy’ increase with independent variables. On the other hand, the estimated negative coefficient for ‘Criticism implies that the level of ‘Sharīʿah legitimacy’ would decline when the criticism regarding Islamic banking products and procedures increases. We find that the ‘Products’ compliance’ (β = 0.423) has caused the most effect on Sharīʿah legitimacy followed by ‘Criticism’ (β = -0.175) ‘Optimism’ (β = 0.151), ‘Performance’ (β = 0.128), ‘Social justice’ (β = 0.083), and ‘Fair treatment’ (β = 0.025). As such, the Islamic banks are required to offer Sharīʿah compliant products in case the Sharīʿah legitimacy has to be enhanced. On contrary, any outside criticism levelled against Islamic banking practices like the consensus fatwa issued locally in 2008 has affected the belief of the respondents adversely. Although, the size of the impact of ‘Criticism’ on Sharīʿah legitimacy is expected to be much lesser than the one to be left if the products were Sharīʿah compliant, still any lapse on Sharīʿah compliance of products will give room to outside criticism and Sharīʿah legitimacy would be adversely affected. Since all variables are significant (p<0.01), even the smaller magnitude of the coefficients does matter and is expected to bring impact on the Sharīʿah legitimacy of Islamic banking practices. Accordingly, people’s attitude of being optimist about future progress of Islamic banking reflects a positive sign that could help building confidence over the Islamic banks. Similar findings have also been arrived at by Loo (2010). But, at the same time, it is expected on the part of Islamic banks to perform better than conventional banks in terms of providing individual attention to the customers, building better image and reputation, and affording efficient services to their customers. Most of the factors in our analysis, built on various dimensions of maqāṣid al-Sharīʿah, cause legitimacy of Islamic banking practices to varying degree. We have also extended our model to include the demographic variables enabling to predict the dependent variable more precisely as they might affect its variance. It was expected that these variables would predict the dependent variable more accurately (Newbold, 1984) and help shaping the relationship better (Argue et al., 1999). The results reveal that F-statistic remains significant for all demographic variables. The adjusted R2 has either slightly improved or remained static except the province of residence of the customers, thereby, depicting firmer relationship of the latter with the dependent variable. The standardized coefficient of the male gender has turned insignificant in explaining the Sharīʿah legitimacy of Islamic banking practices. However, the female gender has depicted statistically significant but negative impact on Sharīʿah legitimacy. The finding is supported by the literature (Ahmad and Bashir, 2014) that women being constrained by mobility are affected less by the religious factors and hence have lesser perception about Islamic banking practices. The other studies like Khan et al, (2007) and Metawa and Almossawi (1998) have, however, excluded gender from their study while evaluating behavior of Islamic banking customers in Bangladesh for the reason that Islamic principles of banking do not distinguish women from men. The estimated coefficients of other explanatory variables have either not or negligibly changed. The inclusion of the gender into our model does not affect the impact of the other variables in regression. Alternatively, the effect of other variables remains robust. Our results suggest that the level of income does not have any statistically significant impact on people’s perception regarding Sharīʿah legitimacy of Islamic banking practices. These results, however, do not correspond to the literature; for example, Gan et al. (2011), where the effect of income was found significant while assessing customers’ satisfaction level in New Zealand’s banking sector. However, our results correspond to certain extent to SBP KAP study (State Bank of Pakistan, 2014) where the incidence 10
  11. of demand for Islamic financial services increases with increase in income level from low to middle and then decreases as income further increases . In our view, the results of our analysis are interesting depicting that the religious preference remains independent of the income levels of the people reflecting that religion is the prime factor in preferring Islamic financial services. Since the age and attitudes are strongly related (Arthur, 1996), therefore, the age has become one of the important attributes to be considered by the banks. Our regression results are highly significant for the young and older categories; however, the relationship has turned negative in case of the former category and positive for the latter, reflecting that the older respondents are more likely to believe in Sharīʿah legitimacy of Islamic banking practices whereas the younger do not. We can infer that the old people (over the age of 50 years) consider the Islamic banking practices Sharīʿah legitimate that might be the result of their increased knowledge and analytical ability about Islamic banking. The relevant literature also finds that older customers (56 years +) were significantly satisfied with the banking services, as concluded by Gan et al. (2011) as compared to the young and middle aged where the relationship was found insignificant. We may infer that Islamic banks are ignoring the vital segments of younger and middle-aged population (e.g. 84.3% of the total respondents in our sample) that are less likely to believe in Sharīʿah legitimacy of the current Islamic banking practices. The situation necessitates to focus more on the young and middleaged customers and pursue them demonstrating Islamicity/legitimacy of Islamic banking to build their confidence. The population of Pakistan, as reported by Government of Pakistan (2015) pertaining to age groups 20-34 and 35-49 years is considered younger and middle-aged respondents respectively, (as in our sample) constitute 82.90% of total population correspond to our sample size. The respondents hailing from Sindh and Baluchistan showed statistically significant relationship with dependent variable; however, the direction of relationship appears negative in the former’s and positive in the latter’s case. We can therefore conclude that the respondents of Baluchistan are more likely to believe in Sharīʿah legitimacy of current Islamic banking practices. The SBP KAP study corresponds to our results in respect of Sindh. The statistical significance in case of other provinces could not be established. The impact of the level of education on Sharīʿah legitimacy of Islamic banking practices does not turn significant for all levels except the lower level of education (primary, matric, vocational, and other). The effect is even negative for middle and master level of education. The literature also supports insignificant results in case of middle education level (diploma etc.) and higher education level (graduation and above) (Gan et al. 2011). Our results are also confirmed by a number of studies, for example Meisenberg et al. (2011) and Hungerman (2011) that the impact of religiosity decreases with the level of education and intelligence. Our positive relationship in case of the respondents who did not go to school is also confirmed by these studies. One may understand that the respondents with no or low level of education might have little capacity to analyze and make out their own outlook and, rather, believe in what they hear and see. However, the positive relationship at the higher level of education, especially in our case, might be due to the presence of the respondents with specialized education in Islamic banking and finance. But, our findings turn contrary to other studies like State Bank of Pakistan (2014) and Dar (2004) [34],[55] concluding a positive impact of education on demand for Islamic financial services, presumably with increased knowledge about Islamic banking (Tara et al. 2014). We may emphasize, as in case of the age group, that the situation requires Islamic banks to devise strategies, specific to different levels of education to convince them about legitimacy of the Islamic banking practices. IV. CONCLUSIONS AND POLICY IMPLICATIONS A. Conclusions The respondents perceived the objectives of Sharīʿah legitimacy to be achieved by the Islamic banks as (i) the social justice is extended, (ii) the products’ compliance with Sharīʿah is ensured, and (iii) 11
  12. expectations of the respondents about excellence in Shar īʿah compliance and social justice are achieved. The outside criticism (by Sharīʿah scholars / jurists outside Islamic banks) on Islamic banking practices has left negative and significant impact on ‘Sharīʿah legitimacy’. The positive values of the estimated coefficients suggest that the customers’ perceptions about ‘Sharīʿah legitimacy’ improves with independent variables. On contrary, any outside criticism levelled against Islamic banking practices, like the consensus fatwá of ʿulamā’ issued from Jamia Islamiyyah Allama Binori Town, Karachi in 2008 labelling Islamic banking as Sharīʿah non-compliant, affects the Sharīʿah legitimacy adversely. However, if the products and practices of Islamic banks conform to the principles of Sharīʿah, the impact of such fatāwá would be lessened. Otherwise, the negative perception about legitimacy of Islamic banking practices would be observed.. The female gender had depicted statistically significant but negative impact on Sharīʿah legitimacy owing to lesser mobility and limited access to the financial services than the men. The respondents’ perception about legitimacy of Islamic banking practices diminishes with increase in income up to medium income group, but it again had risen with further increase in the level of income. In line with our expectations, it confirms association of age with the knowledge and analytical capability. As regards the province of residence, the respondents from Baluchistan (least developed region in the country) were more likely to believe that Islamic banking practices were Sharīʿah compliant. The relationship of Sharīʿah legitimacy with education did not turn significant for all levels of education except the lower one (up-to 10 years of schooling). Our results confirm that impact of religiosity decreases with the level of education and intelligence. Our analysis also infers that the seniors in age (over 50 years) consider the Islamic banking practices Sharīʿah legitimate that might be the result of their increased knowledge and analytical ability about Islamic banking. Gan et al., (2011) also find significant relationship in case of old-aged customers (56 years +) while insignificant relationship with customers’ satisfaction for young and middle-aged groups. One may understand that the respondents with no or low level of education might possess little capacity to analyze and make out their own outlook and, rather, believe in what they hear about the fatwa / pronouncement of the banks sharaiah board as communicated to them by the banks staff. B. Policy Implications The following policy implications have been framed to be considered by the various stakeholders. Managements of Islamic Banks 1. The Islamic finance should be pre-occupied with the wellbeing of the society. That is, the Islamic banks should be required to observe the spirit behind the Islamic principles through their operations devising ways and means that should facilitate redistribution of wealth and widen access to the financial resources. To achieve this end, the Islamic banks are required to consider their social obligation, stakeholders’ interest, rather than that of shareholders only, and Sharīʿah compliance in broader perspective. 2. The Islamic banks, instead of serving mainly the cause of the corporate sector, should equitably extend access of their services to the small and micro-enterprises instead of channeling finance mainly to the corporate sector as being currently practiced. Emphases are required to disburse qarḍ ḥasan to the needy people and charging lower price of the banking services to the small entrepreneurs as compared to the corporate businesses. 3. The Islamic banks must take the notice and devise the strategies to finance the women for home-based and SME production activities. We strongly feel that, women being half of the population of the 12
  13. country should not be ignored and targeted productively by offering women friendly services like women specific branches or counters . Sharīʿah Boards of Islamic Banks The Sharīʿah boards of Islamic banks should consider revisiting the Sharīʿah legitimacy criteria of the Islamic banking practices and include maṣāliḥ based injunctions transpired through maqāṣid al-Sharīʿah to meet normative objectives related to value judgement, distributive justice, and equity. They ought to allocate certain proportion of the financing portfolio towards poverty alleviation pursuits like micro, small farmers and small enterprise finance, equity based modes of finance, and qarḍ for needy. State Bank of Pakistan 1. SBP, in its capacity as regulator, of Islamic banks may take note of the current situation and devise policy to advise Islamic banks to allocate certain proportion of financing to small farmers and microenterprises as mandatory targets. 2. SBP may also consider relaxing regulatory constraints to facilitate flow of funds to the NGO sector in view of its informality, uniqueness, and inability to offer physical collateral in case Islamic banks opt to finance the small and microenterprises. 3. SBP should consider amending the governance framework for Islamic banking institutions by including the requisites maqāṣid al-Sharīʿah. Other Recommendations 1. The academia is the most useful resource to undertake research on various key issues of Islamic banking operations. The institutions of higher education equipped with Sharīʿah and finance knowledge should integrate the Islamic banking industry and realize more Sharīʿah legitimate solutions in diverse fields of Islamic banking and finance. 2. Our research has inferred that young generation believes more in the contemporary Islamic banking system. Therefore, the educational institutions be targeted more in this respect to approach young people in addition to the other segments. REFERENCES Adanza, E. G. (2006). “Research Methods: Principles and Applications”, Rex Book Store, Inc., Philippines. p.186. Ahmad, A. and Bashir, R. (2014). “An Investigation of Customer’s Awareness Level and Customer’s Service Utilization Decision in Islamic Banking”, Pakistan Economic and Social Review 52 (1). p.71 Ahmed, H. (2006). “Islamic Law, Adaptability and Financial Development”, Islamic Economic Studies 13(2), p. 79-101 [Cited from Kamali, M. H. (2000), “Islamic Commercial Law: An Analysis of Futures and Options”, The Islamic Texts Society Cambridge, UK] Ahmed, H. (2011). “Maqasid al-Sharīʿah and Islamic Financial Products: A Framework for Assessment”, ISRA International Journal of Islamic Finance, 3 (1): 149-160 Argue, A., Johnson, D. R., and White, L. K. (1999). “Age and Religiousity: Evidence from a ThreeWave Panel Analysis”, Journal of the Scientific Study of Religion, 38(3), 423-435. p.433-434 Arthur, M. (1996). “Marketing Financial Services”, Macmillan Press ltd. Attia, G. E. (2007). “Towards Realization of the Higher Intents of Islamic Law – Maqasid al Sharīʿah: A Functional Approach”, The International institute of Islamic Thought, USA and UK, p.7. 13
  14. Berrone , P. Gelabert, L. and Fosfuri, A. (2009). “The Impact of Symbolic and Substantive Actions on Environmental Legitimacy”, IESE Business School, University of Navarra, Working Paper No. 778, Barcelona, Spain: Adanza, E. G. 2006. “Research Methods: Principles and Applications”, Rex Book Store, Inc., Philippines. p.186. Bhattacherjee, A. (2012). “Social Science Research: Principles, methods, and Practices”, University of South Florida Scholar Commons Textbooks Collection. p.142 : Accessed 29 September 2015. Blackstone, A. (2012). “Sociological Inquiry Principles: Qualitative and Quantitative Methods”, 4142 Creative Commons, 3.0/ Accessed 18 January 2016. Choong, Y., Wong, K., and Lau, T. (2012). “Organizational Commitment: An Empirical Investigation on the Academician of Malaysian Private Universities”, Business and Economics Research Journal, 3(2), 51-64. p.57 Dar, H. (2004)(. “Demand for Islamic Financial Services in the UK: Chasing a Mirage?”, Economic Research Paper No. 04-11, Creative Commons, Loughborough University’s Institutional Repository, UK. p.7 Dusuki A. W. and Dar. H. *(2005). “Stakeholder’s perceptions of corporate social responsibility of Islamic banks in Malaysia”, Proceedings of the International Conference of Islamic Economics and Finance, Jakarta, 21-24th November 2005. 390-417. p.399, 401 and 410 Dusuki, A. W. and Nurdianawati, I. A. (2007). “Why do Malaysian Customers Patronize Islamic Banks?”, International Journal of Bank Marketing, 25(3), 142-160 DOI: 10.1108/02652320710739850 Echchabi, A. and Aziz, H. A. (2012). “Empirical Investigation of Customers’ Perception and Adoption Towards Islamic Banking Services in Morocco”, Middle-East Journal of Scientific Research 12 (6): 849-858, 854 DOI: 10.5829/idosi.mejsr.2012.12.6.1942 El-Mesawi, M. El-Tahir. (2006). (Translated and Annotated) “Ibn Ashur: Treatise on Maqasid al Sharīʿah”, The International Institute of Islamic Thought, USA and UK 2006. p.5, 94 & 126. Field, A. (2000). “Discovering Statistics using SPSS for Windows”. London – Thousand Oaks – New Delhi: SAGE Publications. p.425 & 648. Field, A. (2009). “Discovering Statistics using SPSS”, SAGE Publications Ltd. London. p.629 & 644. Gan C., Mike Clemes and Jing Wei. (2011). “An Empirical Analysis of New Zealand Bank Customers’ Satisfaction”, Banks and Bank Systems, 6(3), 63-77. p.76 Government of Pakistan (2015), “Pakistan Economic Survey 2014-15”, Ministry of Finance Government of Pakistan, p. 202. Hough, M. J., and Bradford, B. (2013). “Legitimacy, Trust and Compliance: An Empirical Test of Procedural Justice Theory Using the European Social Survey”, in Legitimacy and Criminal Justice: An International Exploration Edited by Tankebe, J. and Liebling, A., New Haven: Yale University Press,. p.5 Accessed on 19 March 2015. Hungerman, D. M. (2011). “The effect of Education on Religion: Evidence from Compulsory Schooling Laws”, University of Notre Dame and National Bureau of Economic Research Cambridge, UAS. Accessed 9 July 2015. 14
  15. Imran , M., Samad, S. A., and Masood, R. (2011). “Awareness Level of Islamic Banking in Pakistan’s Two Largest Cities”, Journal of Managerial Sciences, Jan – Jun 2011, V(I), 1-20. p.8. Islamic Financial Services Board. (2013). “Islamic Financial Services Industry Stability Report 2013,” Malaysia.p.7, 115-116 Accessed on 14 June 2015. Khaleequzzaman, M. Mansoori, M.T. and Rashid, A. (2016). “Sharī‘ah Legitimacy of Islamic Banking Practices in Pakistan - An Evaluation”, Journal of Islamic Business and Management, 6(1) p.87-88. Khan, M. S. N, Hassan, M. K., and Shahid, A. I. (2007). “Banking Behavior of Islamic Bank Customers in Bangladesh, Journal of Islamic Economics, Banking and Finance, 3(2) July – December 2007. p.159-194 and 167 Kharoufa, A. (2000). “Philosophy of Islamic Shari’ah and its Contribution to the Science of Contemporary Law”, Islamic Research and Training institute, Islamic Development Bank, Jeddah: p.55. Kothari, C. R. (2004). “Research Methodology: Methods and Techniques”, New Age International (P) Limited Pyblishers, New Delhi. p.2 & 3. Laldin, M. A. (2013). “Understanding the concept of Maslahah and its Parameters when used in Financial Transactions”. Journal of Islamic Business and Management 3 (2):151-174 Landau, S. and Everitt, B.S. (2004). “A Handbook of Statistical Analysis Using SPSS”, Chapman & Hall/CRC, London. p.295 Loo, M. (2010) “Attitudes and Perceptions towards Islamic Banking among Muslims and NonMuslims in Malaysia: Implications for Marketing to Baby Boomers and X-Generation”, International Journal of Arts and Sciences 3(13): 453-485. p.454 Masood, S., Rehman, S., and Rehman, C. A. (2014). “Cognizing Customer Awareness and Perception of Islamic Banking Products in Pakistan” International Journal of Operations and Logistics Management, 322-336. p.328. Mawoli, M. A., Babangida, I. B., and Babandako, A. Y. (2011) “An Evaluation of Staff Motivation, Dissatisfaction and Job Performance in an Academic Setting”, Australian Journal of Business and Management Research, 1(9) [01-13, December-2011], p.5 Meisenberg, G., Rindermann, H., and Patel, H., Woodley, M. A. (2012). “Is It Smart to Believe in God? The Relationship of Religiosity with Education and Intelligence”, Temas em Psicologia, 20(1), 101-120. 102 Metawa, S. A. and Almossawi, M. (1998). “Banking behavior of Islamic Bank Customers: Perspectives and Implications”, International Journal of Bank Marketing 16 (7), 299-313. Mishkin, F. S. (2003). “Policy Remedies for Conflicts of Interest in the Financial System”, Graduate School of Business, Columbia University and National Bureau of Economic Research. p.8 Accessed 9 July 2015. Mohammed, M. O., Razak, D. A., and Taib, F. M. (2008). “The Performance Measures of Islamic Banking Based on the Maqasid Framework”, paper was presented at the IIUM International Accounting Conference (INTAC IV) held at Putra Jaya, Malaysia, 25 June 2008. p.4 Nenova, T., Niang, C. T. and Ahmed, A. (2009). “Bringing Finance to Pakistan’s Poor: A Study on Access to Finance for the Underserved and Small Enterprises” The World Bank. p.142 Newbold, P. (1984). “Statistics for Business and Economics”, Princeton Hall International, UK. p.547. 15
  16. Nyazee , I. A. K. (2006). “Islamic Jurisprudence (Usul al Fiqh)”, International Institute of Islamic Thought Islamabad and Islamic Research Institute Islamabad. p.47 & 265. Obaidullah, M. (2011). “Financial Contracting in Currency Markets: An Islamic Evaluation”, International Journal of Financial Services, 3(3). Cited from Saleh, N. (1992). “Unlawful Gain and Legitimate Profit in Islamic Law”, Graham and Trotman, London, p.42-43. Ozkan, M. K., Niclpoulou, K., and Ozbilgin, F. (2014). “Corporate social Responsibility and Human Resource Management: A Diversity Perspective”, Edward Elgar Publishing Limited, UK. p.40 Pakistan Microfinance Network. (2009). “Access to Finance Study”, DFID, Department for International Development UK and the World Bank. Pallant, J. (2005). “SPSS Survival Manual: A Step by Step Guide To Data Analysis Using SPSS For Windows (Version 12)”, Allen and Unwin, Australia. p.121 & 188.. Pew Research Centre. (2012). “Pakistani Public Opinion Ever More Critical of U.S.”, Global Attitudes project, Washington D.C. p.29. Accessed 9 July 2015. Rafay, A. and Sadiq, R. (2015). “Problems and Issues in Transformation from Conventional Banking to Islamic Banking: Literature Review for the Need of a Comprehensive Framework For A Smooth Change”, City University Research Journal, 5(2) Article 10, 315-326. Rosly, S. A. (2010). “Sharīʿah Parameters Reconsidered", International Journal of Islamic and Middle Eastern Finance and Management, 3(2): 132-146 Accessed on 26 January 2016. State Bank of Pakistan. (2015). “Islamic Banking Bulletin March 2015”, State Bank of Pakistan, Karachi. p.8. State Bank of Pakistan and Department for International Development UK, (2014) “KAP Study: Knowledge, Aptitude and Practices of Islamic Banking in Pakistan – Executive Summary”, SBP Karachi. State Bank of Pakistan, (2013). “Islamic Banking Bulletin March 2013”, Karachi. p.7. State Bank of Pakistan. (2014). “Quarterly Compendium: Statistics of the Banking System”, Offsite Supervision and Enforcement Department, SBP Karachi. Suchman, M. C. (1995). “Measuring Legitimacy: Strategic and Institutional Approaches”, Academy of Management Journal, 20(3) 571-610. p.574. Tara, N., Irshad, M., Khan, M. R., Yamin, M., and Rizwan, M. (2014). “Factors Influencing Adoption of Islamic Banking: A Study from Pakistan”, Journal of Public Administration and Governance, 4(3), 352-367. p.356. Doi:10.5296/ jpag. v4i3.6677 Zaidi, M. (2010). “A Link Between Poverty and Radicalization in Pakistan”, Pak Institute for Peace Studies, Islamabad. 5 16